09/25/2026
I bought Paul Belasik's "Long and Low" book which is a discussion on the concept of long and low, and does include stretching in Belasik's criticism. While it is interesting and certainly food for thought at the moment, but was more interesting was Belasik's criticism of "modern dressage" in that what we have been breeding for some time (according to Belasik, since WWI).
"In the case of the new sport of dressage (competition dressage), the movement of the horses began to be a premier factor in judging. A growing fascination with hypermobility, especially of the front end, became a craze, including the addition of harness horses into breeding programs to accentuate knee action. With the increasing flamboyance, fundamentals were overlooked and faults in disposition were forgiven. Movement became of utmost importance. Movement was more important than rider position, more important than proper ex*****on of required exercises. It was the number one factor in success in the competition ring aside from politics." He goes on to state that the breeding has also forgotten the ridability of these horses to the point where many may be "talented" but un-ridable or dangerous.
I find this quote extremely interesting as I have had ongoing discussions with a friend over the quality of current dressage horses. The movement has become impure, and almost lame in some instances. She had pointed out the harness horse influence particularly in the KWPN, and sure enough some bloodline research quickly showed how much (a lot) of harness horse influence. It is to the point that myself I now prefer watching the jumper lines more as at least their movement is still fairly correct. In some respects I saw this transition before when I was showing on the Arabian circuit and there was a change about mid-90's to park horse action in everything but "hunter pleasure" and more accurately the sport horse classes. Even my beloved show hack and costume classes became park classes as the Arabian circuit judges directed the rewards to flamboyant Saddlebred type moving horses instead of the correct versatile Arabian who should be able to show English pleasure in the morning and western mid-afternoon, then back to jumping or whatever the rider desired. Now I have little patience for the show bred Arabian, but clearly the dressage bred warmblood has been on a similar path for a long time as well.