19/12/2019
Northern News Services published an alarming editorial in today’s newspaper (see picture below). This local, northern newspaper is meant to represent Yellowknife – the community that has the largest Indigenous population in the NWT. The Yellowknife Dog Trotters Association has spent the last few years fighting for our space within Yellowknife. We are an organization made up of Indigenous families practicing a traditional activity – dog mushing. We feel we, as dog mushers, have a right to belong within the municipal makeup of Yellowknife – we deserve space too. We no longer want to be shuffled off to the far reaching areas of the City, as is what happened to our organization for decades. This time, we decided to fight for our right to belong – using our desire for reconciliation as a means forward. It is only recently that Indigenous people have felt comfortable standing up for themselves within our society. So to put ourselves out there in this way, and then to read an editorial by our local newspaper that degrades us for using tradition, culture, and reconciliation as an argument is upsetting, to say the least. And for once, we feel the need to speak out!
Quoted from the editorial “the dog mushers have been driving the debate into the theoretical, arguing their points in terms of the preservation of tradition, culture, and Indigenous reconciliation. Of course they have. It places them on the moral high ground: who wants to be associated with the horrifying mental image of an Indigenous person being separated with their means of subsistence and travel?” To say this statement has a racist undertone towards Indigenous Peoples is an understatement. The attitude and tone of this statement is that we are using our stance to benefit us (the moral high ground) when our stance is actually the reality of the situation. The question of what will happen to property values is a very colonial view. What about the traditional values? Cultural values? The values that the Indigenous Peoples have had for centuries? Why are these not seen as important as property values? Instead, we’re mocked as trying to use a theoretical tactic for our advantage.
“This argument between mushers and homeowners isn't about denying anyone their way of life, or ripping up decades or centuries of tradition. It's about the reality of hundreds of dogs in one place” First off, the mushers have never complained or been anything besides welcoming to new developments. The argument has always been one sided, and that is the grace lake residents side. The argument is that new developments in this area believe they have the right to oust kennels and push them as far away as possible without understanding the traditional and cultural practices of the Indigenous Peoples that use these dog teams and trails. The hundreds of dogs were in the area decades before Grace Lake residential area was developed. If allowing kennels to set up shop cheek and jowl with family homes is a recipe for disaster, then why did the grace lake residents decide to build in that area knowing full well that dog kennels would always be there and that Kam lake is dog mushing central? The reality is that Grace lake residents bought property and developed houses decades after the dogs were already there. Kam Lake is an industrial zoned area; any residents in this area WILL be exposed to noise pollution at all hours because there are no noise by-laws due to the industrial zoning. The narrative that locating future kennels as far away from grace lake residents is the same narrative the Canadian government has had with Indigenous Peoples through Canada’s history - Move them as far away so we don’t have to deal with them.
“This story isn't about what is fair, or proper, or who is right or wrong. It's not about culture, it's about conflict.” This story IS about culture and the treatment of Indigenous Peoples. Dog mushing is genuinely interwoven into our culture. To say this story isn’t about culture is putting a colonial lens on an Indigenous issue. “Residents are also right to point out that a new location in the south end of what would become the Kam Lake South district is more suitable.” Who has decided this is more suitable? Not the dog mushers or kennel owners. The grace lake residents have decided that. They have taken the large area that was identified as space to grow for dog mushers and whittled it down to a small portion of that area. It needs to be clarified that this area isn’t suitable as there is no access to the south end of Kam Lake and it would take years to develop proper access. Plus the costs of developing the infrastructure would likely put the price of the lots out of reach for any dog mushers. This narrative has strong ties to Canada’s attitude towards and treatment of Indigenous Peoples throughout history.
It’s unfortunate in today’s day and age that this type of attitude still exists and is spread through one of the main community media outlets.