27/04/2025
【DUAD相关判例】
【DUAD Related Ruling】
1）【懷擁罪咎的魔瞳】不是以一個玩家為對象的效果，所以不能对其連鎖發動【精靈之鏡】。
【謳歌死亡的魔瞳】與【撕裂時間的魔瞳】也一样。
2）【懷擁罪咎的魔瞳】的【●我方召喚等級5以上怪獸的場合可以不解放怪獸。】適用之後，仍然需要解放3隻怪獸才能召喚【歐貝利斯克之巨神兵】，因為巨神兵註明【必須】解放三隻怪獸才能召喚。
簡單來說，就是「【必須X】會凌駕於【可以Y】之上」。
3）處理【宇迦御狐之姐妹】的【3】效果時，玩家需要先決定要適用幾個●效果，然後依照●效果的順序來適用這些效果。
③:此卡被破壞的場合可以發動。根據場地區卡片數量選擇以下效果適用幾種。
●對方場上1張卡破壞
●給對方1500傷害
例子：
當處理【3】效果時，場地區域有兩張卡，玩家決定要適用兩個●效果。在此情況下，即使在適用第一個●效果時，選擇破壞對方場地區域的卡，使場地區域只剩下一張卡，這也不會影響已決定要適用的第二個●效果。因此，第二個●效果仍然可以正常適用。
4）【正義傳說 海馬人】的【①:此卡召喚˙特殊召喚的場合可以發動。我方手牌˙牌組˙場上(表側表示)˙墓地3張「青眼の白龍」給雙方確認。之後，我方手牌˙牌組˙墓地「青眼の白龍」1體特殊召喚。】
在處理此效果時，不能選擇手牌、卡組或魔法·陷阱區域中的【青眼亞白龍】作為確認對象，也不能從手牌或卡組特殊召喚【青眼亞白龍】。
原因是：【青眼亞白龍】的【1】效果僅在其以表側表示存在於怪獸區域或墓地中，且效果未被無效的狀態下，才會被視為「青眼白龍」。此外，由於【青眼亞白龍】是「特殊召喚怪獸」，因此【正義傳說 海馬人】只能從墓地特殊召喚那些已經按照正規手續特殊召喚過的【青眼亞白龍】。
5）【原石龍 下界石榴石龍】的【②:此卡在怪獸區存在為限，等級˙階級˙連接數值在我方場上˙墓地通常怪獸數量以下的對方場上怪獸發動的效果無效化。】效果的適用條件如下：
● 對方發動怪獸效果時（在支付cost之前），該怪獸當時的等級、階級或連結值；
● 在對方怪獸效果處理時，自己場上與墓地中的通常怪獸數量是否大於或等於上述數值；
● 該怪獸是從哪裡發動效果的（效果處理時是否仍存在於怪獸區域，並不影響結果）。
例子：
a）在自己墓地存在3隻通常怪獸的情況下，對方發動等級為3的【幻祿之天盃龍】的【2】效果。
由於【幻祿之天盃龍】在作為cost被解放之前的等級為3，且效果在場上發動，墓地中也有3隻通常怪獸，因此該效果會被無效化。
b）在自己墓地有3隻通常怪獸的情況下，對方發動了因其自身效果而變為等級4的【幻祿之天盃龍】的【2】效果。
由於該怪獸在發動時等級為4，而墓地中僅有3隻通常怪獸，因此未滿足【通常怪獸數量大於或等於等級、階級或連結值】的條件，該效果不會被無效化。
c）在自己墓地有3隻通常怪獸的情況下，對方發動等級為3的【幻祿之天盃龍】的【2】效果，但在效果處理時，因其他效果使墓地中的通常怪獸數量減少至2隻以下。
即使該怪獸在發動前的等級為3，但效果處理時不再滿足條件，因此該效果不會被無效化。
6）當我方發動【閃刀姬－零衣】的【1】效果時，對方在連鎖2以【閃刀姬－零衣】為對象發動【墓穴的指名者】；我方接著在連鎖3，以墓地的【閃刀姬－零衣】與【閃刀起動－交閃】為對象，發動【閃刀亞式－雙紐無限門】。
在連鎖3的處理中，【閃刀姬－零衣】與【閃刀起動－交閃】被洗回卡組，導致連鎖2的【墓穴的指名者】失去對象，其效果無法適用。然後連鎖1正常處理，我方從額外卡組特殊召喚了1隻「閃刀姬」連結怪獸。
此情況下，【閃刀亞式－雙紐無限門】的【②:此卡在墓地存在的狀態，我方場上有「閃刀」怪獸特殊召喚的場合，將此卡除外可以發動。將「閃刀姫」L怪獸1體L召喚。】無法發動。
此判例主要說明：
連鎖2或以上發動的速攻魔法或通常陷阱卡，即使該卡的效果已經處理完畢，也會留在魔法與陷阱區，直到整條連鎖完全處理完畢後，才一併送入墓地。
自然的，如果有其他效果讓該卡離場的話，那麼該卡就在那時候離場。
因此，在上述情況中，【閃刀亞式－雙紐無限門】是在【閃刀姬－零衣】的【1】效果處理完畢後，才與【墓穴的指名者】一起被送入墓地，因此不滿足【這張卡在墓地存在的狀態，自己場上有「閃刀」怪獸特殊召喚的場合，】的條件。
1）【Guilt Gripping Morganite】is not an effect that targets one player, so it cannot responded with 【Mystical Refpanel】. The same applies to 【Succumbing-Song Morganite】 and 【Time-Tearing Morganite】.
2）After applying 【Guilt Gripping Morganite】's 【● You can Normal Summon Level 5 or higher monsters without Tributing.】, you still need to tribute 3 monsters to summon 【Obelisk the Tormentor】, because 【Obelisk the Tormentor】 specifically states 【must】 tribute three monsters for its summon.
Simply put, 【must X】 overrides 【can Y】.
3）When resolving 【Ukanomitsune-no-Onari】's 【3】 effect, players must first decide how many ● effects they wish to apply and then apply them in sequence.
If this card is destroyed: You can choose the following effects up to the number of cards in the Field Zones and apply them in sequence (you cannot choose the same effect twice).
● Destroy 1 card your opponent controls.
● Inflict 1500 damage to your opponent.
Example:
When resolving 【3】 effect, there are two cards in the field zone, and the player decides to apply both ● effects. In this case, even if the first ● effect is applied by choosing to destroy the card in the opponent's field zone, leaving only one card in the field Zone, this does not affect the decision to apply the second ● effect. Therefore, the second ● effect can still be applied normally.
4）【Legend of Justice Kaibaman】's 【If this card is Normal or Special Summoned: You can show 3 "Blue-Eyes White Dragon" in your hand, Deck, face-up field, and/or GY, then Special Summon 1 "Blue-Eyes White Dragon" from your hand, Deck, or GY.】
When resolving this effect, 【Blue-Eyes Alternative White Dragon】 cannot be selected from the hand, Deck, or Spell & Trap Zone as part of the confirmation, nor can it be Special Summoned from the hand or Deck.
The reason is that 【Blue-Eyes Alternative White Dragon】's 【1】 effect only allows it to be treated as "Blue-Eyes White Dragon" when it is face-up in the Monster Zone or in the Graveyard, and its effect is not negated. Additionally, since 【Blue-Eyes Alternative White Dragon】 is a 【Special-Summon-Only monster】, 【Legend of Justice Kaibaman】 can only Special Summon 【Blue-Eyes Alternative White Dragon】 that has already been properly Special Summoned by it's own method and is in the Graveyard.
5）【Primite Dragon Nether Berzelius】's 【Negate the activated effects of monsters your opponent controls, whose Level/Rank/Link Rating is less than or equal to the number of Normal Monsters in your field and GY.】 applies under the following conditions:
● When the opponent activates a monster effect (before paying costs), the level, rank, or link value of that monster at the time;
● Whether the number of Normal Monsters on your field or in your Graveyard at the time of the opponent's effect resolution is greater than or equal to the value mentioned above;
● Where the effect of that monster was activated (whether it exists in the Monster Zone during effect resolution is irrelevant).
Examples:
a) When there are 3 Normal Monsters in your Graveyard, and your opponent activates the 【2】 effect of【Tenpai Dragon Genroku】that is level 3.
Since 【Tenpai Dragon Genroku】 was level 3 before being used as a cost, and during the effect resolution, your Graveyard contains 3 Normal Monsters, and 【Tenpai Dragon Genroku】's effect is activated on the field, the effect will be negated.
b) When there are 3 Normal Monsters in your Graveyard, and your opponent activates the 【2】 effect of【Tenpai Dragon Genroku】 which has become level 4 due to its own effect.
Since 【Tenpai Dragon Genroku】's level was 4 before being used as a cost, and during its effect resolution, your Graveyard contains only 3 Normal Monsters, the condition 【Level/Rank/Link Rating is less than or equal to the number of Normal Monsters in your field and GY.】 is not fulfilled, so the effect will not be negated.
c) When there are 3 Normal Monsters in your Graveyard, and your opponent activates the 【Tenpai Dragon Genroku】's 【2】 effect, and due to other effects, the number of Normal Monsters in your Graveyard decreases to 2 or fewer.
Since 【Tenpai Dragon Genroku】 was level 3 before being used as a cost, but due to other card effects, the number of Normal Monsters in your Graveyard decreases to 2 or fewer, the condition 【Level/Rank/Link Rating is less than or equal to the number of Normal Monsters in your field and GY.】 is not fulfilled, so the effect will not be negated.
6）When I activate 【Sky Striker Ace - Raye】's 【1】 effect, and the opponent chains 【Called by the Grave】 to target 【Sky Striker Ace - Raye】; then I chain 【Sky Striker Alternative - Lemnis Gate】 with 【Sky Striker Ace - Raye】 and 【Sky Striker Mobilize - Engage!】 in the Graveyard.
During the resolution of chain 3, 【Sky Striker Ace - Raye】 and 【Sky Striker Mobilize - Engage!】 are returned to the Deck which causes【Called by the Grave】's effect to resolve without effect due to loss of target; then, chain 1 resolves normally with me special summoning a 【Sky Striker】 Link Monster from my Extra Deck.
In this case, 【Sky Striker Alternative - Lemnis Gate】's 【If a "Sky Striker" monster(s) is Special Summoned to your field while this card is in your GY:】 effect cannot be activated.
This ruling mainly explains:
After a Quick-Play Spell or Normal Trap Card is activated in chain 2 or higher, it will remain in the Spell & Trap Zone until the entire chain has finished resolving, at which point it will be sent to the Graveyard.
Naturally, if another effect makes that card leaves the field，then it will leave the field at that time.
Therefore, in the above situation, 【Sky Striker Alternative - Lemnis Gate】 is only sent to the Graveyard together with 【Called by the Grave】 after 【Sky Striker Ace - Raye】's 【1】 effect has finished resolving. Hence, it does not meet the 【If a "Sky Striker" monster(s) is Special Summoned to your field while this card is in your GY:】 condition.
判例參考/Ruling Reference：
1）https://www.db.yugioh-card.com/yugiohdb/faq_search.action?ope=5&fid=23939&keyword=&tag=-1
2）https://www.db.yugioh-card.com/yugiohdb/faq_search.action?ope=5&fid=24171&keyword=&tag=-1
3）https://www.db.yugioh-card.com/yugiohdb/faq_search.action?ope=5&fid=24168&keyword=&tag=-1
4）https://www.db.yugioh-card.com/yugiohdb/faq_search.action?ope=5&fid=24173&keyword=&tag=-1
5）https://www.db.yugioh-card.com/yugiohdb/faq_search.action?ope=5&fid=24172&keyword=&tag=-1
6）https://www.db.yugioh-card.com/yugiohdb/faq_search.action?ope=5&fid=24167&keyword=&tag=-1
#遊戲王
22/06/2025
22/12/2024
![Yu-Gi-Oh! OCG [SUDA] AKATSUKI 2024 Tournament "FINAL MATCH" Blue-Eyes VS Memento (November 30, 2024)](https://img3.localgymsandfitness.com/145/663/1006900691456635.jpg)
02/12/2024
01/12/2024
23/09/2024
01/07/2024
22/06/2024