17/11/2026
A good read for our students/ families.
Finding an exercise, certain activity or different horses hard? Don’t give up!
Teaching Riders Perseverance - When Something Gets Hard, Do We Let Them Give Up?
One of the most valuable things we can teach our riding students has very little to do with riding itself.
It's learning how to work through something that doesn't come easily.
As riding instructors, we've all had students who become frustrated when they can't master a skill immediately. Maybe these students are struggling to pick up the correct canter lead, keep their horse straight through an exercise, or coordinate several aids at once.
After a few unsuccessful attempts, you hear those familiar words "I can't do it." "I don't want to try anymore." "Can we do something else?"
Sometimes as instructors, it is tempting to move on. We don't want students leaving their lessons frustrated and we certainly want them to enjoy riding.
I think there's an important difference between making a lesson enjoyable and making sure a student never experiences difficulty.
Riding is hard but learning any worthwhile skill can be hard and if we constantly remove the challenge the moment a student becomes frustrated, are we really helping them?
1. TEACH STUDENTS THAT STRUGGLING IS PART OF LEARNING
I think one of the first things we need to change is how students view mistakes. Not getting something right on the first, fifth, or even tenth attempt doesn't mean they're incapable of learning it. It means they're still learning!
I would much rather have a student who is willing to make mistakes, listen to feedback, and try again than one who only wants to attempt exercises they already know they can do. Of course, that doesn't mean asking students to repeat the same unsuccessful attempt over and over, which brings me to my next point...
2. PERSEVERANCE DOESN'T MEAN REPEATING THE SAME MISTAKE
There's a big difference between encouraging persistence and simply making a student continue an exercise that isn't working. If a rider has attempted something several times without improvement, I think it's our responsibility as instructors to change our approach. Maybe we need to simplify the exercise, break the movement into smaller steps, explain the aids differently, or identify a missing foundational skill.
Sometimes the student isn't giving up because they lack determination, they're giving up because they genuinely don't understand what we're asking them to do and that's something we need to recognize.
3. DON'T ALWAYS LET FRUSTRATION DECIDE WHEN THE EXERCISE ENDS
This is something I feel strongly about, provided the horse and rider are safe and the task remains appropriate. If a student becomes frustrated and immediately wants to abandon an exercise, I don't think we should automatically agree. Instead I might say "let's make it a little easier and see if we can finish with one good attempt." Perhaps we shorten the exercise, return to a simpler version, or focus on accomplishing just one part correctly.
The goal isn't to force them through something they're genuinely frightened of or physically unable to do. It's to help them discover that a difficult moment doesn't necessarily mean they need to quit. Sometimes that one small success is enough to completely change their attitude.
4. RECOGNIZE EFFORT, NOT JUST RESULTS
I think instructors sometimes place so much emphasis on whether the rider successfully completes an exercise that we overlook the effort involved. A student might not have achieved the perfect transition but perhaps they corrected their position without being reminded. Maybe they recognized what went wrong and made a better decision on the next attempt and those improvements deserve recognition.
Instead of only saying "good job!" when the exercise is completed correctly, explain what the student did better. "Your transition wasn't quite there yet but your preparation was much better that time." That gives students something tangible to build on!
5. KNOW THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN ENCOURAGEMENT AND PRESSURE
This is where good judgment becomes especially important. A frustrated rider isn't necessarily a rider who needs to be pushed harder. Sometimes they're mentally exhausted, physically tired, overwhelmed, or losing confidence. There are also situations where the horse is struggling, uncomfortable, or simply doesn't understand the exercise.
Perseverance should never mean ignoring those things. We need to recognize when to encourage another attempt, when to change the task, and when it's genuinely time to stop. There's no educational value in pushing a horse or rider beyond what they're capable of handling safely.
6. LET STUDENTS EXPERIENCE THE SATISFACTION OF WORKING THROUGH SOMETHING DIFFICULT
I think some of the most memorable moments in riding lessons happen after a student has genuinely struggled with something. Perhaps they've spent several lessons working toward a particular skill. They've made mistakes, become frustrated, questioned whether they could do it, and then one day, everything finally comes together.
That feeling of accomplishment is different from the satisfaction of doing something that was easy all along. They've learned that progress doesn't always happen immediately and that patience, effort, and good instruction can eventually produce results. That's a LIFE lesson they'll carry well beyond the riding arena.
One final thought...
I don't believe our job as riding instructors is to make every lesson easy. Our job is to make learning achievable, appropriately challenging, and rewarding.
There's nothing wrong with a student finding something difficult. There's nothing wrong with them becoming frustrated occasionally, either. What matters is how we help them respond to that frustration.
Do we teach them to abandon something as soon as it becomes uncomfortable? Or do we help them develop the patience, problem solving skills, and confidence to work through challenges?
I think we can encourage students to persevere without turning riding lessons into an unpleasant experience. Sometimes that means pushing a little. Sometimes it means changing our teaching approach. Sometimes it means recognizing that they've done enough for the day. Knowing the difference is part of being a good instructor.
Riding instructors, how do you handle students who want to give up when an exercise becomes difficult?
Do you encourage them to keep trying, simplify the task, or move on and revisit it another day?
I'd love to hear how you teach perseverance without allowing frustration to take over the lesson.