Play It Again Sports - Carmel, IN

Play It Again Sports - Carmel, IN Play It Again Sports Carmel Sells New and Used Sports and Fitness Equipment. We guarantee the lowest price on all new products.

We service all fitness equipment and warranty the used products. Trade in and save, or sell for cash! We sell NEW sporting goods and fitness equipment from major brand name manufacturers. We sell High-Quality USED sporting goods! We’ll buy your slightly USED GEAR from you. You can also trade in that USED GEAR for top quality, NEW or other slightly used athletic gear. Great prices on NEW and used treadmills, home gyms, weights, and the hottest new elliptical trainers and exercise bikes! Top-quality Proline golf equipment, lacrosse, hockey, baseball, Adidas soccer, football, and more. Before you buy any new or used sports gear, visit
Play It Again Sports Carmel --- your family headquarters for new and used sporting goods

We just received our shipment of the limited edition Tiger Shark 2027 Louisville Slugger Supra USSSA stop by our store a...
09/16/2026

We just received our shipment of the limited edition Tiger Shark 2027 Louisville Slugger Supra USSSA stop by our store any time and snag one before they’re all sold out!

New release of the 2027 Rawlings Icon in all leagues, BBCOR, USA Baseball, and USSSA! We offer specialty pricing in stor...
09/16/2026

New release of the 2027 Rawlings Icon in all leagues, BBCOR, USA Baseball, and USSSA! We offer specialty pricing in store and we can also custom order whatever size and weight you may need! Stop in anytime and check out this sweet new release! Vote which bat looks the best!

Got hockey gear collecting dust? Clean out your garage and earn cash for it today!
09/14/2026

Got hockey gear collecting dust? Clean out your garage and earn cash for it today!

09/14/2026

Here’s a quick look at what our store entails here in Carmel, IN we have what you’re looking for no matter what the sport or activity is! We encourage you to sell or trade your old gear with us and save while you shop for new gear! We offer cash on the spot and also store credit to use towards new purchases! Feel free to call with any questions or stop in anytime!

Make a power play at Play It Again Sports! Bring in your hockey gear and get paid for quality used sticks, pads and more...
09/13/2026

Make a power play at Play It Again Sports! Bring in your hockey gear and get paid for quality used sticks, pads and more.

In partnership with CCM, we’re now buying quality used hockey gear! Earn cash for helmets, sticks, gloves and more.
09/12/2026

In partnership with CCM, we’re now buying quality used hockey gear! Earn cash for helmets, sticks, gloves and more.

Your gear deserves another shot. Bring it in, get paid and give your gear a chance to play again. Let’s make hockey more...
09/11/2026

Your gear deserves another shot. Bring it in, get paid and give your gear a chance to play again. Let’s make hockey more sustainable!

From skates to sticks—when you bring us the gear you’ve outgrown, we’ll make sure it finds a new player who needs it. Ea...
09/10/2026

From skates to sticks—when you bring us the gear you’ve outgrown, we’ll make sure it finds a new player who needs it. Earn cash for your hockey gear today - presented by CCM!

🧊 🏒Get paid for the quality used skates, sticks, helmets and other hockey gear you no longer need!
09/09/2026

🧊 🏒Get paid for the quality used skates, sticks, helmets and other hockey gear you no longer need!

09/09/2026

Address

2332 E 116th Street
Carmel, IN
46032

Opening Hours

Monday 10am - 7pm
Tuesday 10am - 7pm
Wednesday 10am - 7pm
Thursday 10am - 7pm
Friday 10am - 7pm
Saturday 10am - 6pm
Sunday 12pm - 5pm

Telephone

+13178486044

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Play It Again Sports - Carmel, IN posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Play It Again Sports - Carmel, IN:

Shortcuts

Share

Category