09/04/2026
Three Reasons Why Aikido Doesn’t Work
Aikido is a modern (1920s) derivative of the often brutal art of classical Japanese Jujutsu. Like judo, aikido’s techniques were altered so that they could be practiced repeatedly and safely by anyone willing to train.
Can aikido be effective for self-defense? Yes. But like any traditional martial art, there can be problems with its actual effectiveness.
Scripted Attacks. Many aikido schools rarely step outside of static or non-violent grabs and hand attacks designed for learning. If an aikidoka (student) wants to evaluate his or her techniques, they should train with partners who will use non-scripted attacks. This often changes the way any technique works.
Lack of Practical Knowledge. Modern Aikido is not a fighting art; it is a mental, physical and spiritual path to enlightenment. As such, students rarely get hit and that’s a problem. In order to really grasp how these techniques could work, you need to step outside the box and learn some basic punching and kicking skills. And you need to spar often. The best aikido people I’ve ever met had a background in striking arts and/or combat sports. Getting punched and kicked is educational. “Everybody has a plan until they get punched in the face.” Mike Tyson
In this video, for example, I’m applying a throw called “sumi otoshi.” Notice how I softened up my partner before I attempted this throw. At close range, this becomes less of a traditional projection and more of a takedown.
Physical and Mental Readiness. Martial arts training is worthless if you are overweight and out of fighting shape. Belts and titles don’t matter. What you did in the past doesn't matter. A serious martial artist follows a disciplined fitness routine that includes resistance training, explosion and cardio. And he or she maintains a fairly strict diet that avoids lousy food and too many substances. This type of discipline coupled with martial training leads to mental readiness.
Looking for a school that teaches practical aikido? Call us at 513-600-2260 or visit us at https://www.tatsudojo.com/martialarts