X-treme Whitetails MN

X-treme Whitetails MN

Comments

12-3-2018 muzzleloader 8 pointer, 140 6/8 gross
Please be aware and share
GREAT ARTICLE PLEASE READ

The Facts on Antler Restrictions and Deer Hunting
By: Guest Contributor for Deer & Deer Hunting | March 27, 2015
222
Spike buckAntler restrictions seem to have popular appeal in many places. But, popular appeal could also cause ARs to become a bit like the old “buck law.” Under buck-only hunting everyone knew that the herd would grow if you didn’t shoot “mother deer.” And, it became nearly a sin to consider shooting female deer because you not only killed the doe but also killed her progeny. It was “like killing hundreds of deer with one shot.” The popular appeal of this protective mentality became a major obstacle to prescribed antlerless harvests and persists in some corners yet today.

By Keith R. McCaffery

There is potential for a similar problem with ARs. It seems to make common sense that by not shooting small antlered deer that these deer will survive to have much larger antlers as they mature. Some hunters are so hooked on this idea that they are demanding state agencies to impose mandatory ARs. But, it is doubtful that they are aware of the biological impacts and track record of ARs.

Antler restrictions may be voluntary or mandatory. On large club properties or shooting preserves the club members or owner may voluntarily establish rules that require that a buck exceed a certain antler condition or Boone & Crocket score before it is eligible to be shot.

Some places might require that antler beam spread exceed the width of the deer’s ears. But, most often it is a point count. State-mandated ARs commonly require that a legal buck have one antler with at least 3 or 4 points depending on the local potential for antler growth. This AR is intended to protect from harvest the majority of yearling bucks.

One might argue that Wisconsin already has had ARs. Prior to 1957, legal bucks had to have at least one antler with a 1-inch or greater fork. This restriction was discontinued in large part because of the number of spikes that were accidental-illegal kills and left in the woods, plus there was no biological reason for the restriction.

Hunters have a wide range of opinions about antler restrictions in all parts of the country.
Hunters have a wide range of opinions about antler restrictions in all parts of the country.

Why ARs?

ARs are normally sought only in areas that are heavily hunted for bucks. High hunter numbers and buck-only rules will insure that a high proportion of bucks will be killed. Under such conditions, it follows that the next year’s crop of bucks will be composed mostly of replacement yearlings.

A young age structure should not be confused with the normal age composition of a productive herd. In any herd, whether heavily hunted or not, the largest age class will be the youngest age class; that is, fawns. The largest “adult” age class will be yearlings. Each older age class will be smaller than the one preceding it. Some hunter’s expectations are unrealistic as they fail to recognize basic population dynamics. No productive herd has a high proportion of “mature” bucks except in relative terms.

Wisconsin has high hunting pressure in that it ranks 4th nationally in numbers of deer licenses sold. Prior to 1990, bucks were heavily exploited especially in farm woodlot areas of central and southern Wisconsin. Unrestricted buck seasons, plus limited antlerless quotas, meant hunting was focused on antlered deer. The majority of hunters wanted to be successful and most wanted venison. Thus, there was competition for bucks.

Since 1990, Wisconsin has struggled with herd control. Bag limits on antlerless have been greatly increased and hunting opportunities lengthened. This has shifted mortality away from antlered bucks and focused more of it on antlerless deer. The result is that there is an older age structure of bucks now than at any time in many decades.

Hunters have been able fill their freezers with antlerless venison while “saving” their one buck tag for a big one. If the “big one” doesn’t show, they still have been successful and have meat. Meanwhile, more bucks survive. Wisconsin has led the nation in production of Boone & Crocket bucks during recent years. All this has been happening with no deliberate effort to “produce” mature bucks.

Past and Recent AR Trends

Western states have had the most experience with ARs specifically designed for the purpose of producing larger antlers. These have been applied to both mule deer and elk. California tried ARs as early as 1937. Most other Western states followed. But already by the 1970s, it was becoming clear that ARs were not achieving their goal. At best, they were merely shifting the bulk of the harvest from yearlings to 2.5-year-old bucks.

As studies continued, two major disappointments were discovered.First was finding an unacceptable level of accidental-illegal kill of animals with inadequate antler condition.Counting points in the wild can be difficult.

The second was noting that ARs focused harvests more heavily on the mature males, virtually wiping them out. One cannot produce “old” bucks by targeting old bucks. They found better age structures were achieved when harvests were spread across all age classes of males. States also found that the best way to have more mature animals was to limit license sales; an option that would not be popular in most Eastern states.

Attempts to discontinue ARs led to a long struggle between wildlife biologists and hunters and this struggle was reminiscent of ending the “buck-only law” in Wisconsin. But by 1998, all Western states except Colorado had discontinued statewide ARs and even Colorado dropped their statewide rule by 2003. Three states, including Colorado, retained some individual units with ARs as a compromise to pacify those sportsmen that continued to demand ARs.

However, popular appeal forced New Mexico to reinstate ARs for a short time, but discontinued them again in 2008. Several Eastern states including Arkansas, Pennsylvania and Mississippi soon mandated statewide ARs. By 2012, 22 states were entertaining ARs on a broad or limited basis for a variety of reasons.

So, it pays to be aware of the issues as demands for mandatory ARs may be coming yet to a neighborhood near you.

Antler restrictions may work better on private land with voluntary decisions than on a statewide "one size fits all" basis and mandated by a wildlife agency.
Antler restrictions may work better on private land with voluntary decisions than on a statewide “one size fits all” basis and mandated by a wildlife agency.

Where ARs Work

ARs tend to work where there are privatized herds and exclusive hunting. Club properties or leases and shooting preserves can employ ARs and achieve older bucks. Limited entry, alone, would lead to having more old bucks. But, these situations are far from what most Midwesterners would consider to be public hunting.

The “official” reason for employing ARs in some states was to focus mortality on the antlerless segments of the herd. Accidental-illegal kill as experienced in the West may not be as much a problem so long as Eastern states continue to experience over-abundant deer and have surplus bonus permits for antlerless deer. But, as herds are reduced to responsible numbers and competition for venison and success increases, accidental-illegal kill of bucks may again be a concern.

Another approach

An overlooked tool for producing older bucks is the employment of Earn-a-Buck (EAB) where a hunter must harvest an antlerless deer before being eligible to bag an antlered buck. As initially applied in Wisconsin and New Jersey, EAB tended to reduce buck harvest rates by nearly 40 percent. Some of the reduced buck harvest was no doubt caused by hunters having to pass up a buck because they were not yet eligible to shoot one. But, another factor may be that once having shot an antlerless deer there was less need to shoot a buck for venison. By holding back for a “bigger” buck, many hunters go home with no buck but are still “successful” and happy. The result is an older buck age structure.

Of course, the use of EAB is temporary as it depends on having surplus deer. EAB has been demonstrated to be one of the most effective herd reduction tools available for public hunting. Once herd size is lowered and approaches population goals, EAB is discontinued and its affect on extending the buck age structure ceases. Note that a “pre-qualification” provision, where an antlerless deer shot in the prior year qualifies a hunter to shoot a buck in the following EAB year, reduces the proportion of surviving bucks as does the strategy of earning a second buck (EA2B) by shooting an antlerless after one buck has already been taken.

Other Downsides of ARs

A primary goal of ARs is to provide some protection for yearling bucks so that they can be harvested at age 2.5 or older with increased antler size. The effect is to protect all bucks with small antlers while creaming off mature bucks and those yearlings with larger racks. While this may or may not have long-term genetic effects on the herd, studies in Mississippi have found that the surviving members of a yearling age class will have significantly smaller antlers during their lifetime after ARs have been applied.

A secondary motivation for imposing ARs is to correct what is perceived as “distorted” s*x ratios. It is common in productive herds for about one out of 5 deer to sport antlers prehunt in the fall if buck harvest has been unrestricted. Some believe this is an indication of “grossly distorted” s*x ratios when in fact the prehunt adult s*x ratio is rarely more than 2 does per buck and the fawn s*x ratio is near 1 to 1. The combined s*x ratio for most of these fall herds is near 3 females to 2 males.

To the extent that adult s*x ratios are adjusted from 2 does per buck to closer to 1, as might occur with ARs, herd growth rate will be slowed. This can be good or bad depending on objectives. Most hunters have wanted rapid growth to produce and sustain high harvests. But, slowed growth would be beneficial for controlling herds where deer are overabundant and hunter demand is low.

Another problem with mandatory ARs is the matter of enforcement and penalties. Low fines might reduce compliance. High fines might increase the number of abandoned dead deer. And, what should the fine be for a young hunter that mistakenly shoots an illegal buck?

A final concern is the perception created for the non-hunting public. ARs are nearly impossible to divorce from so-called “trophy” hunting. The general public has strongly supported hunting when the focus has been on producing food or for controlling wildlife populations. But, ethical challenges arise when they perceive that the purpose is for mere sport, recreation, or trophies. Mandatory ARs force even meat-hunters to appear to be trophy hunters.

Parting Shot

ARs seem to have popular appeal because, like the “buck law” of earlier times, the restrictions seem to make sense. However, the consequences of imposing ARs have not been fully appreciated by many people. Very simply, you cannot produce more old bucks by targeting older bucks. That, too, should make good sense.

Years of experience and research in Western states has shown that ARs, when mandated for public hunting, do not result in more deer or larger-antlered deer. Can we expect different results in Eastern states?

— Keith McCaffery is a retired wildlife research biologist from Wisconsin.

This is a site for the X-treme Whitetail Hunters that have nothing else on their minds except dropping "Mr. Big". outdoors - hunting

Operating as usual

11/12/2020

Larry JR Designs

03/18/2020

White Knuckle Productions WebShow & Podcast

On Saturday, March 21st we are doing a WKP Team Shed Hunt. We are doing it in WI with our team. This shed hunt will hopefully be the start of a tradition in Todd's memory.
-
We would love for any of you that are out these next few days to post your pictures to take part in this special weekend.
-
Thank you all in advance for your participation. It means the world to all of us!❤️

12/21/2019

Mark your calendar, January 4, Blooming Prairie! Hunt for a cure, & WIN some sweet gear. Raffle tickets are just $20; there’s also games & silent+live auction items.
Message the Coyotes Fur Cancer FB page for details.
#CoyotesFurCancer #huntfuracure

Flyers are up and around town. Raffle tickets are available at B to Z, The Pizza Cellar, or message our page.

12/17/2019

The Sportsmen Party

I double dog dare you....

12/17/2019

ABC World News Tonight with David Muir

ON THIN ICE: A man came to the rescue of three deer stranded out on a frozen lake in Canada while he was skating on his lunch break, safely pulling them back to shore. https://abcn.ws/2EpxEd3

12/10/2019

FailArmy

Deer me!

wideopenspaces.com 10/12/2019

Colossal 50-Pound Mille Lacs Muskie Caught on Video

Jay Stephan

wideopenspaces.com Mille Lacs produces some giant fish. If you don't believe us, just check out this video of a 50-pound muskie caught from this legendary Minnesota lake!

08/23/2019

Hockey Beast

😂😂😂

08/02/2019

Fox News

SHOCKING: Watch as a Kentucky Fish and Wildlife team zaps an entire school of invasive Asian carp with “electrofishing” equipment to stun and collect them as part of a study on the species, which officials say is threatening the region’s fishing industry by reducing the food available for native fish.

07/30/2019

MN Deer Density Initiative - MDDI

What the...!

3 buck limit in most of Zone 3 this year. Statewide youth season? Lots of intensive harvest.

07/30/2019

Driven with Pat & Nicole

This last week our lives were turned upside down as we mourn the loss of a best friend & best hunting buddy to our son Carson. As most of you know, Carson, our 15 year old is an avid outdoorsman. His Best Friend & hunting partner Aidan Miller (16 years old) went to heaven a week ago today, of natural causes, while doing what they loved doing best, casting a line together in our pond here at the Driven Headquarters. The bond these boys shared was nothing short of incredible. I’ve never met anyone that didn’t tell you how amazing of a young man Aidan was and how he lit up a room by walking in. After witnessing this weeks events, we would like to say a special thank you to Dan & Karen for sharing their son with us over the years. The family foundation that you have built is an example for us all to live by. The Faith you have and have shared with your children and our community is nothing short of inspiring and something all families should model. The numerous trips we were able to share with Aidan to the cabin, hunting camps, fishing outings, deer classics and all the laughs in between there was never a dull moment between those two boys.

We want to thank everyone for your kind words who have reached out to us but most importantly for your prayers. We ask you to continue to pray for Strength, Comfort & Healing for the Miller Family, our son Carson and Logan & Fisher Dittrich.

Aidan Daniel Miller
October 9, 2002 - July 22, 2019

07/23/2019

Respect The Game TV

Accurate

Hey look a deer 👀
.
Lethal Products

07/13/2019

WDAY TV News

Massive muskie's dinner! Check out this viral video Cody Wolters of West Fargo captured while kayaking.

More information here --> http://bit.ly/2sUZQ4v

07/13/2019
rochester.secondstreetapp.com 07/12/2019

Check out Priority Construction Services.

Will you help a couple Admin out by VOTING Priority Construction Services for "BEST OF THE BEST" PB Readers Choice Award? 🚨 Voting ends this Sunday, JULY 14th! 😀

* Best Roofing Company
* Best Windows & Siding

rochester.secondstreetapp.com Vote for your favorite businesses.

06/05/2019

Ouch!

"Hey Doc. If you have time today while you're out on calls, would you mind coming by and take this deer antler out of my horses' ass??!"

06/02/2019

Coyote Creek Outdoors

Bravo!

We think this is awesome!

05/01/2019

KIMT News 3

You’ll be filling out paperwork to be handed down Grandpas old shotgun. No thanks

One provision would expand criminal background check requirements for all gun transfers, while the other would allow authorities to temporarily take guns away from people deemed an imminent threat to themselves or others.

04/26/2019

Deer Camp in 1918, $16. Who’s in?

04/13/2019

Oh my damn

I have a soft spot for whitetail, so... the bear would possibly be toast 🤷🏼‍♂️ Nature yes, but keep it off my lawn! 😁

Imagine seeing this go down in your back yard😨

04/13/2019

Fox News

A border collie didn't think twice about risking her life to save her small friend who was behind a moving car.

04/07/2019

Western Nebraska Big Game Hunting

Tailgate mount... cool or no?

04/07/2019

Whitetail Overload

The younger generation is our answer to keeping the traditions alive!

04/03/2019

Fox 9

What kind of a-hole does this?

It's becoming quite an eyesore as spring arrives in Minnesota.

03/28/2019

Minnesota Gun Owners Caucus

Federal Ammunition President Jason Vanderbrink has sent this letter to several Minnesota State Representatives in whose districts Federal operates outlining the company's opposition to House File 8 - the "Universal Gun Registration" bill.

"If enacted, HF 8 will render most of Minnesota's scholastic trap shooting, learn-to-hunt, and similar educational programs inoperable By prohibiting the loaning and borrowing of firearms by lawful individuals, HF 8 would effectively outlaw youth shooting sports. These prohibitions would impact thousands of Minnesotans whose participation in youth shooting sports is promoting an ethos of safety, teamwork, and dedication amongst the next generation of Minnesota leaders."

03/28/2019

KARE 11

A Minnesota lawmaker would like to give schools the option of adding firearms safety, hunting, trap shooting, archery and fishing to physical education classes.

https://kare11.tv/2UdUNZE

03/18/2019

Chasing Trophy Whitetails

Hope yall are having a great and successful spring turkey season.

03/16/2019

Whitetail Overload

Interesting watch. Wife already said no...

Here's a really unique way of hunting!

03/16/2019

Stokerized Stabilizers

foxnews.com 03/14/2019

Australian man blocks bow and arrow attack with his phone: police

Woah! This guy got lucky

foxnews.com An Australian man was able to block an arrow from hitting him by using his phone, police said.

03/14/2019

The National Desk - TND

Bravo!

Timofey Yuriev and Kira, his dog rescues two dogs in an icy reservoir.

https://www.instagram.com/kira_nose_the_way/
facebook.com/kokomel
facebook.com/tyuriev

https://cir.ca/2XS4EDg

03/14/2019

In case you haven’t noticed our Second Amendment is under attack. This is ridiculous!

Local anti-gun groups Protect Minnesota and Survivors Lead have signed on to a new gun control proposal in Congress requiring background checks on all ammunition sales.

Are you ready to go through a NICS check when buying a box of .22 for the range?

Videos (show all)

Let’s see those “BIG BUCK” videos!!  😁🦌💵
Getter done Lizzy!!! 😉
Lizzy was lucky today!!
Missouri spring snows
Another cool video from Nick Pitzer.
That's gonna leave a mark!
Great morning in the stand! Lots of gobbles! Come on in boys!
Sneak Peak From Rushford during the 1st gun season.  He did bust me before i took him, I had to turn and get the camera ...
7 YDS, Pretty cool even he is small!
Hope his father shows tomorrow, he will be a shooter in 2 years if he makes it that long.
Just a couple nice bucks I thought I would share from last night. It was an awesome night being out amongst God's creatu...

Location

Telephone

Address

Plainview, MN

Opening Hours

Monday 8am - 5pm
Tuesday 8am - 5pm
Wednesday 8am - 5pm
Thursday 8am - 5pm
Friday 8am - 5pm
Saturday 8am - 5pm
Sunday 8am - 5pm
Other Plainview gyms & sports facilities (show all)
Long Haul Fi****ms Long Haul Fi****ms
26289 530th St
Plainview, 55964

We are a retail Fi****ms & Accessories Shop.

Bulldog Youth Wrestling Bulldog Youth Wrestling
500 W Broadway
Plainview, 55964

Bulldog Youth Wrestling is a program for youth ages preschool-6th grade to learn the sport of wrestling in the Plainview-Elgin-Millville area.

Baus Horses Baus Horses
Plainview, 55964

Mark Baus is an established Western Pleasure trainer in the AQHA & APHA industry.

Plainview Powersports Plainview Powersports
625 N Wabasha
Plainview, 55964

Full line of Kawasaki products The area's largest Team Green dealer

House of Iron Fitness House of Iron Fitness
328 W Broadway
Plainview, 55964

House of Iron is an upscale fitness center in downtown Plainview, with a wide variety of equipment. Owned by Brandon Reiter a certified personal trainer.

Plainview Wellness Center Plainview Wellness Center
240 W Broadway
Plainview, 55964

Cardio, weight training, fitness classes

Just For Kix - Plainview, MN Just For Kix - Plainview, MN
52668 275th Ave
Plainview, 55964

Just For Kix is a leader in dance instruction. We offer proven technical training, a focus on teamwork and a respectful experience to our students.

Bella Salon Bella Salon
329 W Broadway Ste 1
Plainview, 55964

Big City Style, Small Town Prices!Come in and enjoy one of our many services we provide.

Piper Hills Golf Course Piper Hills Golf Course
25233 534th St
Plainview, 55964

Piper Hills Golf Course in Plainview, MN 3,086 yards of golf from the longest tees for a par 36. The course/slope rating is 69.4/120. Designed by Ray Keller, the Piper Hills course has been open to the public since 1967.

Cross Fit 508 Cross Fit 508
1 George St
Plainview, 95134

At Crossfit 508, we combine kettle bell skills, gymnastics (especially rings and floor work), Olympic weightlifting, rowing, jumping and running with thing

Steffen's Belgians Steffen's Belgians
Plainview

Academy of Martial Arts Academy of Martial Arts
417 West Broadway
Plainview, 55964

Learn self defense! Great for confidence discipline,respect,flexibility,and focus. For ages 3-99 yrs old. Call now and receive 4 FREE CLASSES. 507-269-9164