30/04/2025
FOOTWEAR SELECTION &HAPPY FEET SA
-The following may seem an overkill.
-Repetition is in context of a specific question/aspect.
-Suggest skimming post and eclecting value for You.
PHYSIOLOGY VS NEEDS
-People choose footwear for various uses.
-We have very different feet from each other.
-We can have pairs for multiple/specific use.
-The journey of many miles starts with a footstep. Your life is largely in your hands.
-Your legs are your biggest calorie burners.
-Look after feet and joints for a long, mobile life!!
-This is for mere mortals who want to get
moving, fit and go places.
-It is important to realise that even speciality shops need to move stock they have! You believe everything a salesperson says at your own peril!
-If you consider trying on shoes with a Foot Type/Heel Drop/Features(FTHDF)not made for you, you could land up with shoes that "feel" comfortable/look good, but after km's, conditions and inclines, you may realise you have made a mistake.
-You could get lucky and the "Feelgood" shoes will work for you, especially if you are younger, fit and stronger, so your body can make the necessary adaptations without a "transitioning" phase and/or exercise program.
-Be informed and try to do it more right first time!
-Make sure you do plenty km in the shoes and are happy, before you tackle a more demanding or faraway event.
-If you are choosing footwear for shorter events where you are moving fast, you may want a more snug fit for better grip/sensitivity to the ground.
-Do at least 100 meters in a shop with socks to be used, before taking a decision.
-A chat with those who have gone before can help.
-For starting in the park, your comfy sneakers or running shoes are good, to see if it is for you.
-If you feel like you need more info, are not sure, or the Sales Data/Salespersons are vague, do some more homework.
-Options: A better selection of footwear can be made once your needs, foot variables and conditions expected are known.
runrepeat.com and runnersworld.com are brilliant for seeing what is popular, highly rated and recommended
_____________________________________________________
BE OBJECTIVE AND PRIORITISE FEATURES
-It may suit you to look good in the woods, but if that is more important than suffering, march on!
-Quite often it is hard to find a pair that will tick all of your boxes.
-Stores usually sort sections by activities with suitable features.
A)KNOW YOUR FOOT TYPE
(Neutral/Pronation: Over-Under)
-You can do the wet foot test. Google.
If you have the cash/medical aid, check with a sports physio or foot medical specialist and no one less qualified.
-The selection of boots hardly allows for foot structure.
-If you have pronation issues and run, you probably will have found a structured/suitable model and/or orthotics. Selecting hiking footwear thereafter, mostly made for Neutral feet, may then require orthotic insoles.
-A good podiatrist may know of brands/models that will be more friendly to your foot type and body, after a proper foot analysis.
-David Ives in Hikers SA is one gent who makes sense and enjoys the outdoors.
B)DO YOU NEED/ ARE YOU GOING TO USE ORTHOTICS/DIFFERENT-ADDITIONAL INSOLES
-You can take up excess space to finetune a fit, or if you are going to carry heavy and want more cushioning. Think about changing insoles or adding a uniform 3-5 mm insole, like the Aptonia 100 from Decathlon. Mine have taken about 1000km including rucking with a third of my body weight. They are one size. You use your standard insoles as a template, then cut them to size.
C)SIZES
-For many km, you may want to go 1/2-full size up:
>Feet swelling.
>Accomodating layers of socks/thicker weights for different temperatures.
>Making sure your toes do not touch the front going downhill.
>An additional/custom insole.
-Trying on a shoe for YOU, is more important than the number claimed.
-See if half sizes are available: Sometimes a retailer only has full brand sizes, whilst the brand factory outlet or shop abroad, may have half sizes, in the widths required.
-In SA we talk UK sizes. Make sure that is what you are looking at for reference to start!
-For an exact metric, some stores have a step-in frame.
-Most brand tags or boxes show comparative standards.
UK, US, EU.
-When shoes are made, your foot structure, and the amount, type and positioning of materials used; can effect your fit into the particular size. Or Model.
(Foot physiology above your soles can be different in mass and shape. A shoe can thus be too tight or loose, even after lacing).
-Some brands have various models, in which you may find a better fit than your normal UK/US/EU sizes.
-A finger width in front of your outermost toe is a rough guide.
-If you have wider feet, look at models with "widish" noted in reviews.Or offerings like New Balance with 2E(Wide)/4E(Extra Wide). Why New Balance or standard Nikes work for me.
-South Africans have wider feet. The lot of us mostly. Please, marketing managers! There was a time when I was spoilt for choice, more than 15 years ago. More brands and models now, less that fit!
-Players like Salomon, On-cloud and Kalenji are popular, but seem to not have more wider options available locally.
-Size nomination can be erratic by manufacturers, so best to try footwear on first
(Why I dont buy any off the web, even for upgraded models)
D)HEEL DROP(HD)
-Google/Wiki "Heel Drop" as a starter.
-This is a well written article explaining heel drop:
https://www.zappos.com/c/what-is-heel-to-toe-drop
So what is Heel Drop then? Difference between heel/sole mm and footbed/sole mm totals.(Stack Heights) Also called "Offset".
-Important to note, what manufacturers claim as HD, vs that measured in a Lab, can have huge differences. RUNREPEAT do a Lab test, where they cut the various shoes in half to measure manufacturer CLAIMED stack heights and determine ACTUAL HD. Incredibly, there are major differences.
-HD is normally shown on display models in store.
-Much depends on how fast you want to move and what you are presently running/hiking and exercising with, or have been wearing.
-With Low Drop(+-4-6mm)-0 HD(LD), your calves have a longer range of motion. So if you have always worn footwear, from say 10-12mm; then that is what your calves, achilles n' body have adapted to. If you select LD shoes, without "Transitioning" downwards(calve and stretching exercises)you can "rip" a calf or do numerous other forms of damage. People who have made a transition downwards, swear by the benefits of extended motion.
-I get away with 8mm HD offroad as heel strike is not as severe on the softer stuff. Landing on grass and cushioning make it hard to figure ideal HD. Trial and error.
-The fitter I get, the more the wear on shoes moves from heel to midfoot and toe.
-My thoughts are that with hiking boots, especially if you are carrying a heavy pack, moving slower, you heel strike earlier, so some mm+ may be good for heel compression.
-Some of the brands I used to enjoy, now have a wide range, but in 8mm(Actual?) and less Heel Drops. In 10-12mm I used to really enjoy New Balance, Nike, Saucony, Asics, Adidas.
-It is tempting to try Hoka, Altra, Vivo etc because of plush cushioning, OR at the opposite end, minimalism. These are largely LOW/ZERO HD....Careful!!
-Start slow or transition downwards with a program. Youtube have good vids thereon.
-Your muscles, calves especially, ligaments and tendons, need to settle in their new range of movement. More or less!
-If you were more active at some stage in your life, it may be good to recall the model of footwear you were moving with, then find out and start with the same Model/Heel Drop(Many have continued)before you transition upwards or downwards. You may be fortunate to still have a pair of shoes you were comfortable in.
E)SELECTIONS FOR LADIES IN SA
Someone lamenting the dire selection:
I posit the reason for less variety of ladies boots in SA, and much stock that does not move for men too, is that many brand marketing teams are asleep. We have wider feet, especially Dutch and Ethnic Saffas I believe. So the inappropriate ranges brought in just sat there. It made sense not to re-stock them. This is true to trail and running shoes. You need to start with your foot type and heel drop required. You can go 1/2 to a full size up if you know your comfortable UK size. Sizes are rated on dimos of feet, but the amount and flexibility of your uppers including insoles can give you a different sense of comfort. The reason New Balance do so well in SA, is that their ranges and models with space for toe splay, and a selection of width options, allow you to dial the fit in to where you want it. I believe this running shoe size situation correlates to Hiking Boots/Crossovers.
-"Best" would be best for you! As a lady that may not necessarily be a LDS shoe, given the possibility of your foot structure being different to the norm catered for by a manufacturer or model.
-Some ladies with wider feet and more flat arches may find happines in MNS shoes.
-Colour is probably the least important aspect, if you want a comfortable experience. However, if you are someone whose priority is to look good in the stix, it can be most important...๐
-Salomon, Keen, Merrel &Hitec are popular...
F)FEATURES FOR SPECIFIC PURPOSES
OTHER FACTORS
-There are considerations more serious runners make like whether they strike(Toe-Midfoot or Heel), weight of shoe, energy return etc.
-Outersoles-Regular Mud(Confuguration: Lugs, length, grooves and spacing for easy clean?)
-Cushioning(Plush, medium, minimal?)
-Midsoles(Energy return, ridgid, flexible?)
-Shank-Rockplate(Full/half/Twothirds...)
-Dunk&Dry Or Waterproof?(Breathable or Goretex-Waterproof/Resistant.
-Warmth, Insulation against cold(Snow, ice...)
-Use with waterproof socks for versatility?
(eg Dexshell-Sealskinz....)
-Attachments for anklets/gaiters?
-Toe guards.
-Too much aeration can let fine sand in.
-If you are using Chainsen/Yaktrax, then a lowcut hiker may have more rigidity than a trail shoe.
-Mountaineering Boots and Crampons are a subject on its own.
G)GENERAL NOTES
-You may have to make tradeoffs when considering options, including budget.
-If you know your FTHDF and find the best footwear for YOU, there is a better chance of having a happy body and feet long term.
-Knee and hip replcements are expensive, inconvenient and unnecessary, if you select the right footwear and train more sensibly. Minor damage to cartilage and ligaments can effect your mobility.
-Reviews: There is much to look at when selecting footwear, but if models have worked their way up the ratings for specific foot types, and everyone wears them, they should be good for a look at.
-See eg Youtube: Darwin On The Trail/Dixie if you are contemplating longer/throughikes abroad and how to deal with hiking on ice and in snow, things bears etc.
-When something fits me well on sale, I buy a few pairs.
-NEVER use vinegar on any shoes. My outer soles on a pair of Nikes that I took years to find, just peeled off! ๐
-I prefer a design/materials that are comfy from day one and
don't need 'breaking in'.
-As such, I enjoy Inov8, but in limited models.
I have done over 750km in Parkclaws. Outersoles last, but uppers split after +-500km. Know that a tight fit for grip will possibly do that in all shoes. No need to diss the brand!
-The absence of overt fine grooves/lug configuration and compounds used means they stick to rock and after a muddy run, a simple 10 sec hose spray clears debris. Then they can be left in the sun. Mwah!!
-Look forward to trying the G-series(Graphene)
-I have a pair of old Nike Air Alvord 10's that will not die. New Nike trail shoes are a worthy look-at on specs and positive reviews. Wild Horse, Pegasus Trail etc.
_____________________________________________________
H)ALL THAT MAKES ME HAPPY
ROAD RUNNING SHOES DRY
-Neutral 10mm HD
-New Balance 880 V10-13 2E width.
-The NB 1080 is hugely popular but 8mm HD.
(In 2025 they are sporting 6mm HD. Older 10/8mm HD may still be available at discount prices. Suggest getting a few pairs on Black Friday if they work for you!! )
-This old guy may be able to transition downwards by 2 mm on road. Near killed my calves using Saucony X 4mm HD's!!
-The Nike Pegasus range work well, going 1/2 size up, but I just dont get the mileage that I do out of New Balance on soles and uppers.
ROAD RUNNING SHOES-WET
-Neutral 10mm HD
+Grooves for water shedding &Some temperature insulation.
-Old Nike Pegasus Shield 34's. That is it for me. They breathe a little unlike the Goretex models I have tried. A slip has consequences!
-Perhaps just move slower on a wet surface.
ROAD SHOES-HEAVY CARRY PACK TRAINING
-Neutral 12>10mm HD
-For plenty heel compression.
-Older Nike Pegs work for me now.
-Brooks, Saucony and Mizuno may warrant a visit as they have had 12mm HD.
TRAIL/ALL TERRAIN/PARKRUN SHOES
-Neutral 8-10mm HD
-Mixing it up on Asphalt/Blacktop/Tar, Gravel and easy Trails.
Inov8 Parkclaw 275
New Balance Hierro V6-7
EG: MORE TECH NEEDED/SPECIFIC TERRAIN
-EG Where you have plenty Rock, Roots, Mud etc.
(Rockplate for sharper rock.)
-Neutral 8-10mm HD
Inov8 Trailroc 285
_____________________________________________________
I)HIKING BOOT SELECTION SA ACROSS SEASONS
1)Given changes in conditions:
-Surfaces/Terrain/Seasons.
>Blacktop, trail, rock
>Water, mud
>Snow, ice
>Sand
-Medium origins/volume surrounding a foot.
(Vertical, horizontal, Immersion/depth...)
-Duration of usage/exposure.
(Continuous, dunk...)
-Foot workrate, temperature.
(Heat>perspiration>condensation/breathability.
Cold>circulation>freeze/insulation)
2)Then preventing accidents, suffering eg blisters-skin softening, and infection can be a challenge that requires some strategy and an appropriate selection of footwear/accessories.
3)SUGGEST: THREE PAIRS at least:
Suggest Wear 1-Carry 1 for conditions.
>1x PAIR EACH HIKING BOOTS with soft &flexible mid-height collars, 2/3 shanks. For rollover protection, especially in river beds and moraines abroad, with a load on your back.
Some peeps do well in trailshoes only.
-DRY CONDITIONS: 1PR Breathable uppers.
Material must breathe, but keep fine sand out.
(Pukka mids or speedpacking crossovers)
-WET CONDITIONS: 1PR Waterproof uppers.
(Pukka mids or speedpacking crossovers)
-SOLO-WILDERNESS: 1 PR Leather uppers.
(Mids with material thick enough to deal with abrasion and a snake strike?
>>1x PAIR TRAIL SHOES Lowcut collars with stone shield and lugs that grip/can be easily cleaned. Heel drop to match your running-walking shoes with consideration for heel strike cushioning with a heavy load. Also for long flat sections/trails and a change of shoes at night, whilst the other pair are drying out or eg a sole has detached! Or for moving fast.
DRY&WET CONDITIONS: 1 PR Highly Breathable,
dunk, drain &dry. With Waterproof socks where needed.
-If you are in really cold climes, consider something like the Salomon Snowcross/Nike Zoom Turbos with raised bo**ie mid-like that are waterproof, have a slightly higher soft collar and are zipped-velcroed for a better seal without collar agitation(It must stick to and move with your ankle)
-Goretex supposedly breathes. Allegedly works better when cold. Some proprietary materials do an at least equal job, in my limited estimation.
______________________________________________________
CROSSOVERS
-The Inov8 Mid Crossovers between a Hiking and Trail Running Shoes are simply incredible. Here conventional wisdom suggests going a size up.
In recent years, there has been a movement away from heavy, inflexible uncomfortable boots that need longer to be worn in...Towards either Trailshoes or a Crossover Hybrid(CH) between a mid, Lowcut Hiker and Trailshoes.
If you look at Runrepeat(Hiking Boot search)or many other review sites, with the various ratings, then the following are examples available in ZA as popular or close to CH choices:
8-12MM+HD
Salomon X-Ultra 3 or 4 Mids.
Inov8 Roclite
0-6MM HD(LD)
Altras
Inov8
Hoka Tor
On Cloud
______________________________________________________
RAINPANTS
For years I simply pulled rainsuit pants over leather boots and kept two cut sanwich bags with elastic handy, in case there were deep puddles. I had wet feet occasionally when dunking with no loopseal around the ankles.
-Rainpants go over everything and improve the sealing, offsetting water running into your footwear.
-A 1.5-3mm bungee loop around ankles works well.
-Pants with zips and velcro are good for putting on/taking off without removing your boots, but do not seal as well as a close fitting rainpants.
-Use or make a hem to insert the bungee cord with a small sliding lockmech!
______________________________________________________
WATERPROOF SOCKS.
-I tried a pair of Sealskinz. There are other good brands like Dexshell. You need to see if they are for you. In certain conditions, they could save your toes. There is a variety of thicknesses and heights for varying conditions, with merino or bamboo yarns on the inside to control microbes, odours and breathability.
Stateside neoprene is used in varying thicknesses, like flipper socks, to provide extra insulation.
If the sock is big enough to fit another on the inside, then you should be able to layer for insulation from the cold or to wick away/absorb perspiration.
-Layering socks and pairs extra work better for moisture management for me.
-Drynamix liner, midweight merino for winter/blend for summer.
-Cotton may kill in the mountains, but in summer cotton socks work well for me.
-Keep your toenails short and rounded so you do not make holes in socks... and lose toenails.
______________________________________________________
PREVENTING BLISTERS, ODOUR& FUNGI ETC
-Walk or run your footwear in before you go.
-Layering socks reduces friction but should not faciliate bunchup.
-Look after your feet, change or wash those socks.
-Air &dry your feet at night or during stops.
-If you feel a ni**le, stop and look at the problem.
-I keep the bottom of a pair of ladies stockings to put over socks to reduce friction.
-When a hotspot does not vanish, I use a piece of eg cereal/soup box cut to the shape of the problem area.The rough part goes against shoe, shiny against sock. Wet a little so it sticks and kinda forms as required. Practice.
-Talking blister management has many approaches. In agreement is that you should not lance them, but do keep them clean and covered. Treat as a wound if they burst.
-Needless to say, running and walking barefoot to harden feet, along with clean footwear and socks, will make them more hardy and less susceptible to blisters...
Some peeps use meths to harden feet.๐ค
Lekka blou voete!!
______________________________________________________
HOW MUCH MILEAGE SHOULD ONE EXPECT OUT OF FOOTWEAR?
-The performance you get out of a particular pair of boots(same brand- model), can vary for a multitude of reasons.
If you look at eg, Runrepeat's Top Hiker review/rating system, a more general view can be gleaned comparatively.
-Often Drifters have quite a few that are well-rated, recommended by the site and popular with hikers. You can then compare brands-models in one shop. And fit them. It is not unreasonable, like with running shoes to expect at least 600-800+ km. To get these km's whilst your feet remain happy, is the challenge.
-Your classic wear-in boot with leather upper, quality stitching-bonding and vibram sole can give you moderate comfort, plenty km. A boot that is highly comfortable from day one, flexi-meshed and cushioned, can become less comfortable as it "bottoms out" and toenails abrade the upper mesh.
-I have resoled 2xpairs with leather uppers 3x times before 1xpair died. In volcanic ash I killed a pair of Hitecs in a day. One hard kick against a rock can weaken an outer sole attachment..
-For a balance of needs, including good wear, I use Salomon X-Ultra GTX Mids for the wet and Inov8 Roclite Mids(8mm HD) for heat-vent conditions. Drifters have the Inov8 345 in GTX (8mm HD). Perfect for speedpacking.
-Remember there are many popular boots, like Altras.... that are zero-low drop!!
-My fav hiking boot evva is a Salomon GTX7. It has lugs on the ankle for a semi-auto crampon if chainsen/yaktraks etc are not for you, and it is flexible enough to do big km's. I managed to get a second pair on Gumtree. Griffs Pawnshop in Edenvale has a few pairs.
_____________________________________________________
SHOPPING SA
The downside of shoe and gear review sites is that not everything is available in SA at a bricks and mortar shop to try on. I have a love for happy feet, but have seldom paid full price for footwear and try having a specific shoe for a specific event. To save:
Black Fridays
Nike Factory Outlet: June Sales(Hard on BF)
Sportsman's Warehouse Yellow Ticket(+1/3BF)
____________________________________________________
SUNNY SA
I black out my brand logos so that I am not mugged or killed for a pair of shoes. But if someone is desperate, should we offer up our shoes so our lives are spared? Is getting out in groups the more safer option when there are more people to take from? Oh crrapp, who knows??
My wearable is square and plastic looking so as not to scream it is worth as much as a cell phone. Put those expensive things away!
____________________________________________________
RETHINK/SIMPLIFY HIKING FOOTWEAR FOR SA
IN DEMANDING/VARYING CONDITIONS:
-Whilst options are split between Dunk &Dry or Waterproof, do you really want to try drying cold/wet feet at night whilst it is still raining and the wind howling outside, eg atop the Berg?
-If you are hiking up or down hills, the water runoff should stop you from standing in deep pools. Rivers can be crossed, eg in your sandals or aquabo**ies... The object then is to keep your feet dry!
-Having rainsuit pants over midcut boots or crossovers should suffice. Or use an anklet that seals well. For a quick dunk and not have water ingression!!
-If you are going to move fast in dry conditions, then a breathable boot, crossover or trail shoe may be better.
A)EVENT
TO START: EG 5KM>THEN ANOTHER:
PACE:Walk 45-60/Jog 30-44/Run
900+ shoes reviewed and cut in half
We've dissected more than 900+ shoes to give you the most in-depth reviews. We buy all shoes with our own money, and every shoe is wear and lab-tested extensively.