18/11/2026
What if the story we’re telling ourselves isn’t the whole story?
This weekend, we had the pleasure of hosting a clinic with Britta Bruns - Rebalance mind and body, we explored how our mindset and body awareness influence our interactions and relationships with horses.
We welcomed some new horses to the yard and used a variety of liberty interactions to put these ideas into practice.
One of the key takeaways was to practise observing behaviour without immediately attaching meaning to it.
Our brains are incredibly clever. They’re wired to make connections, recognise patterns and fill in the gaps. But sometimes this ability works against us.
We can be so quick to attach meaning to what we observe that we skip an important step: simply observing. We miss the opportunity to stay curious, consider alternative explanations and recognise that there may be more than one story to tell.
Let’s take a horse approaching us with their ears back.
The observation:
“Their ears are back as they approach me.”
The stories we might tell ourselves:
- She’s grumpy today.
- She’s being disrespectful.
- She doesn’t like me.
We see this particularly often when observing interactions between horses.
A horse chasing, kicking or biting another horse.
The observations:
- Horse A is chasing Horse B.
- Horse A bit Horse B.
- Horse B kicked Horse A.
The stories we might tell ourselves:
- Horse A hates Horse B.
- Horse A is bullying Horse B.
- Horse B is being bullied and is defending themselves.
Here’s the thing. These stories can feel real and make perfect sense, but that doesn’t mean we’re seeing the whole picture.
When we’re quick to label, we lose sight of curiosity. Our subsequent observations become coloured by the story we’ve already created. We start noticing things that reinforce our interpretation, and before long, everything seems to fit.
It was these recurring narratives and patterns of conflict in human relationships that led psychiatrist Dr Stephen Karpman to develop a model called the Drama Triangle in 1968.
The Drama Triangle describes three roles people can adopt in difficult interpersonal dynamics:
- the Victim
- the Persecutor
- the Rescuer
When we decide one horse is being bullied, we can quickly assign Horse A the role of Persecutor and Horse B the role of Victim. Before we know it, we’ve appointed ourselves as the Rescuer.
But what if there’s more to the interaction than we’re seeing?
When we observe without immediately attaching a story, we give ourselves the opportunity to gather more information and consider different interpretations.
What if we’re observing boundary-setting, communication or relationship dynamics that we don’t fully understand?
Horses communicate physically. A pinned ear might progress to a threat, a bite or a kick. These are normal ways horses communicate and escalate their boundaries, although sometimes injuries happen.
Of course, we need to recognise genuine welfare concerns and intervene when necessary. But removing every risk can also mean removing opportunities for relationships, communication and natural social experiences.
And sometimes, if we’re honest, our desire to eliminate risk is partly about protecting ourselves from the dreaded vet bill or an injury affecting our ability to ride the horse. That’s understandable, but it’s worth considering the story we tell ourselves. Are protecting the horse or are we protecting our own financial comfort or riding goals?
One of the best pieces of advice I’ve ever been given is this:
“If you’ve created an environment where horses have the freedom to move, friends within a herd, and access to resources, what happens in the paddock is really none of your business.”
It’s advice I’ve had to work hard to put into practice!
For years, I regularly inserted myself into herd interactions as the rescuer. I intervened, separated horses and tried to manage situations according to the stories I was telling myself.
The result?
Unstable herds. Horses who weren’t given the opportunity to establish and communicate their own boundaries. Natural social behaviours being interrupted and, honestly, a whole lot more stress.
That doesn’t mean ignoring injuries or genuine welfare concerns. It means learning to distinguish between what we’re actually observing and the meaning we’re attaching to it.
Sometimes the most helpful thing we can do is pause, observe a little longer and resist the urge to become part of a story we may not fully understand.
Less labelling. More curiosity. More observation. And a little more trust in the horses.
It’s been wonderful to have these discussions on the yard this week, through the clinic, groups, behaviour consultations and liveries. It’s amazing what we notice when we pause and examine our own narratives.
What stories have you caught yourself telling about your horses? Have you ever changed your perspective after taking a step back and simply observing?
Share your experiences with us below. There’s so much we can learn from each other 🥰