08/11/2026
Well said!
Is inclusive education really for everyone?
Last night I read a research paper by Kathy Cologon, Is inclusive education really for everyone? Family stories of children and young people labelled with ‘severe and multiple’ or ‘profound’ ‘disabilities.’
What I found particularly interesting was Cologon’s discussion of the paradox of inclusion itself. She questions the very notion of including children *into* mainstream education, rather than providing an equitable, anti-biased education for everyone from the outset.
I’m currently studying inclusion as part of my master’s degree and the more I read, the more I find myself questioning what we actually mean by inclusive education.
We talk about including children into mainstream schools, but doesn’t that suggest that mainstream education already exists for a particular group of learners and that everybody else has to be accommodated within it?
We seem to have created an education system around an imaginary pupil who learns in a particular way, develops at an expected rate, demonstrates their understanding through particular methods and achieves certain outcomes at certain ages. When children don’t fit that expectation, we identify their difficulties and put additional provision in place to help them get as close to it as possible.
But why are we starting there?
Surely an inclusive education system should begin with the understanding that children are different. They have different abilities, needs, interests and ways of learning. Those differences shouldn’t be something that we have to accommodate afterwards. They should be part of what we consider when designing education in the first place.
When a pupil joins a school, our starting point should be to consider what that pupil needs to access everything the school has to offer. What might need to change within our existing provision? Do we need to adapt our teaching, our environment or our expectations? Do we need additional expertise or resources? What barriers might prevent that child from participating fully in the life of the school?
Instead, I think we frequently approach things from the opposite direction. We have an established system, we identify where the pupil doesn’t fit and then we try to provide enough support to enable them to function within it. To try to ‘fix’ the pupil because they are seen as ‘broken.’
This is where the models of disability become particularly interesting.
We talk about inclusion in ways that appear to reflect the social model of disability, with an emphasis on removing barriers and making education accessible. Yet so much of what happens in practice seems to reflect the medical model, where the difficulty is located within the pupil and the response is to provide interventions intended to address that difficulty.
Of course, children sometimes need individualised teaching and interventions. I’m certainly not suggesting otherwise. But there is a difference between providing specialist support that enables a child to access education and using that support primarily to make the child fit an existing system.
It made me think about Number 2 and his experience of school.
He was cognitively very able, particularly verbally, but struggled significantly with reading and writing. The school provided additional learning support, yet much of what he experienced was an attempt to improve the skills he was struggling with rather than finding ways for him to demonstrate the abilities he already had.
He was given easier work, despite understanding what the other children were learning. After leaving the school, he told me, ‘I could do their work. I just couldn’t write it.’
His difficulties with written work had become more important than his ability to understand the curriculum.
His learning support also took place during assemblies, something I only discovered after he left. On one occasion, he missed receiving an achievement certificate because he was attending an intervention. Another child brought the certificate back to the classroom and tossed it at him, saying something along the lines of, ‘Oh, you got this in assembly.’
The provision that was supposed to support his education was actually excluding him from opportunities to participate in school life and celebrate his achievements alongside his peers.
I find that particularly interesting now because, from the school’s perspective, it had identified a difficulty and put provision in place. It could demonstrate that something was being done to help him achieve the expected outcomes.
But what was that provision actually achieving, and what was it costing him in terms of belonging, participation and how he understood his own abilities?
This was something that Cologon’s research brought into focus for me. Inclusion is not simply about being educated in a mainstream setting. The experiences described by families in the paper demonstrate how exclusion can continue within supposedly inclusive environments and extend beyond school into friendships, relationships and participation in the wider community.
I think we need to question whether our approach to inclusion is sufficiently ambitious. We seem to spend an enormous amount of time identifying individual needs, planning interventions and making adjustments, but perhaps not enough time questioning why our existing educational systems create so many barriers in the first place.
Universal Design for Learning is one approach that interests me because it starts from the principle that learner variability should be anticipated rather than treated as an exception. It asks us to think about the curriculum, teaching and opportunities to participate before individual children encounter barriers.
That doesn’t remove the need for specialist provision, but it changes the starting point.
I would also suggest that the further children progress through the education system, the more rigid some of these expectations become. Rather than adapting the education being provided, we increasingly seem to move children into different sets, different classrooms, different units and sometimes different buildings. We can end up calling this inclusion because the children remain on the school roll, without questioning whether they are genuinely participating in the same educational community.
I think this is the paradox that Cologon’s research has made me consider. We are trying to include children within a system that continues to define what a learner should look like, rather than building a system that recognises the diversity of learners from the outset.
We talk about removing barriers to education, yet so often our response is still to try to change the child rather than the education we provide.
Perhaps genuine inclusion requires us to question the very idea that some children need to be included, rather than recognising that education should belong to everybody in the first place.
Emma
The Autistic SENCo
♾️
Photo: Me. In my kitchen.